All dinners include choice of potato (Baked, Puffs, French Fries, Seasoned Skins, Cheesy Bacon Mashed), Homemade Clam Chowder, and Coleslaw. Please NO substitutions.

*ALL PRIME RIB orders MUST be placed at least one day in advance due to our slow roasting process.*

Cheese Curds
Mozzarella Sticks

Cold Items:
2LB HOMEMAKE clam chowder or Homemade Salads (upon availability)
2LB container Hot Beef (Frozen)

Seafood Full Orders
Lake Perch
Deep Fried Haddock
Broiled Haddock (regular or cajun)
Deep Fried Walleye Pike
Fantail Shrimp
Fresh Broiled Shrimp
Hand Breaded Jumbo Shrimp
Cajun Shrimp Scampi
Seafood Platter (perch, blue gill, pike, haddock, shrimp, scallops)
Haddock Delight (broiled haddock topped with bread stuffing, crab meat, carrots & mushrooms, melted mozzarella cheese) (Friday and Saturdays excluded)
Broiled Scallops (16)

Half Orders of Fish
Deep Fried Perch
Deep Fried Pike
Deep Haddock
Broiled Haddock
Fantail Shrimp
Broiled Shrimp

18oz Porterhouse - Market Price
Stuffed 9oz Tenderloin (mozzarella cheese, bacon & mushrooms) - Market Price (Friday and Saturday excluded)
Petite Tenderloin 6oz - Market Price
Small Tenderloin 9oz - Market Price
Large Tenderloin 18oz - Market Price
Small Ribeye 16-18oz - Market Price
Large Ribeye 22 oz - Market Price

Baby Back Pork Barbeque Ribs
Half Rack
Full Rack

Prime Rib
*All Prime Rib orders MUST be placed a day in advance*
Queen 32oz - Market Price
King 72oz - Market Price
Super 116oz - Market Price
Extreme 160oz - Market Price

Includes 9oz Tenderloin OR 16oz Ribeye and your choice of…

Deep Fried Haddock
Broiled Haddock
Deep Fried Pike
Fantail Shrimp
Broiled Shrimp
Cajun Shrimp Scampi
Deep Fried Scallops
Broiled Scallops (8)

Children’s Menu 
Mac’n Cheese bits and French fries
Hot dog and French fries
Chicken strips and French fries

Orders can ONLY be placed through the Black Otter telephone 920-779-6975 starting at 3:30 pm and MUST be placed directly with someone. Do NOT leave a voicemail or message on Facebook wit your order as they could be missed. Additional phone lines and staff have been added for your convenience. Feel free to place your orders days in advance.

All orders must be picked up on Dewey Street.
We will bring the order to you.
Thank you, we truly appreciate your business!